An open invitation to those in a similar position

It has been a while since I blogged and I have been meaning to get back into it. I now have a reason to do so. In 2022, 6 months after Kelly passed away, I was invited to be a participant in a PhD research study into the fathering experience of South African widowed fathers, who parent and raise their children. This enabled me to meet the nicest of person, a lady by the name of Elna Sutherland who was in the process of obtaining a doctoral degree in Psychology.

Elna asked to meet with me and I was invited to answer several questions that would contributed towards her research. Questions such as “what was your relationship like with each of your children before the passing of their mother? What is your relationship like now?”. “What are the challenges for you as a father? What do you find the most difficult about being a single parent?”. The conversation was thought provoking and I shared as willingly and as honestly as I could.

Elna was incredibly empathetic and had a real passion for the subject. She spoke about the good that she hoped that would come from the research. Ultimately there being more appreciation for the unique challenges of a widowed father. Perhaps there even being more forms of support for those in need. We have stayed in contact and she has kept me up to date on the research. I hope to read the final paper and take note of its observation. Elna has now been invited to present her research at the International Congress for Psychologist in Prague. This is a chance to share the topic and preliminary findings on an international level. I am sure that it will be extremely insightful and well received.

The primary reason for this was post was to say that Elna is also looking for further contributors to the study. If you are one of those fathers who would like to share your story and assist her research, please reach out to her on elna@sutherlandqs.co.za. You are also welcome to contact me and I will put you in touch. The Stoics talk about “acts for the common good”. This might be your opportunity to do so.

Living with regret isn’t easy

Emily asked me a question the other day and it caught me by surprise. “Daddy, what would you do differently if you were able to do it again?” I am not typically a person who hopes to change the past. Instead, I try and focus on making amends and changing the future. I gave Emily a half-assed answer to the affect that although I often wish that things were different, there wasn’t anything that I could think of that I would have done differently. Emily, wanted to share her answer to the question and stated that she wished that she had spent more time with mummy and that she hadn’t fought with her so much. That she had been a better daughter. My heart caught in my throat.

One of the conversations that Kelly and I had on the morning of her passing had a similar theme. When the realization set in that the end was very near, Kelly told me that had she known that this would be the outcome, that she would have done things differently. At the time, it felt like the conversation was one that we might come back to. There wasn’t an opportunity to go into any great detail on the day. I think that Kelly was referring to her treatment plan but there might have been more. I have subsequently thought that given the chance again, that maybe we should have just taken some time off, to go and check-off the things on Kelly’s bucket list. To spend more quality time as a family for her benefit. That could have possibly been a better experience to that which we went through in her final months.

Emily and I had her conversation again a couple of days later. It was obviously something that has been weighing on her mind. It’s hard to re-assure a child that they don’t need to feel a certain way, that their mom loved them regardless. That they were the most precious thing in her world and that they don’t need to feel any guilt or regret. The best I could do was to re-assure Emily that she was entitled to her feelings and that she could always talk to me about them if she wished. That her mom loved her and wouldn’t want her to experience any angst in terms of their relationship. She seemed ok with that for the most part but I don’t think that it made her feelings go away. That might take a little time.

I would have liked to talk to Kelly again about what exactly it was that she meant, should she have been able to ‘do things differently.’ It is a question that I will never really know the answer to. I can try and guess at what she meant but it would all be theory. The lesson is that we have to think hard about our choices as we only get one opportunity. For now, I will do my best to help Emily not get too caught up in the regrets. To acknowledge them but rather concentrate on the positive memories and experiences. Hopefully that helps in the long run.

Understanding the complexity of 50/50

Ethan and I had a conversation in the car home from parkour. I forget what triggered the discussion, but we started talking about how he felt about the day that mummy died. As he has got older and his vocabulary has grown, it has been fascinating to get a deeper insight into his emotions and views on the topic. In this case, he explained that he was ’50/50′ in terms of it being a sad day and a happy day. “Happy?” I thought. That is an interesting emotion to refer to under the circumstance. I had to probe a little further.

“It was a sad day because it was the day Mummy died!”. The look on Ethan’s face showed that this should have been obvious. “Yes, of course” I said, “but why were you happy?”. “Well,” he started, “because after that I met Ada*”. (Ada is the children’s au pair, and a person that has come to be of great assistance to the children and myself). “That makes perfect sense” I responded. “You probably wouldn’t have met Ada if mummy hadn’t passed away”. The discussion moved on and we continued the drive home.

Thinking about it later, I reflected that Ethan’s explanation was less about the day that mummy died, and more about his outlook on the scenario as a whole. To say it differently, it was a very sad life event, but Ethan does recognise some positives that have come from it. It is re-assuring to know this as it speaks to resilience. And resilience is a critical requirement for a longer-term healthy outcome. It is also good know that he likes the au pair…thankfully we made the right decision on that front too.

One year later and life has moved on. That thought alone makes me very sad when I think too hard on it. I keep reminding myself that we have to keep pressing forward. We have to choose to see the 50% that offers positivity and happiness. It helps me to think that we are not leaving Kelly behind. It is that we are bringing her with us in a different capacity. I think that the Kelly would have appreciated that.

*Ada is not the au pairs real name.

Today is not a normal Saturday

Kelly Bree

Today is not a normal Saturday
The reason being that you are gone
No longer around us, nor a part of us
Oh, how we miss how brightly your light had shone

Today is an anniversary for our family
The day that was chosen for you to pass
We will remember you and treasure it
although our happiness on this day will be sparce

We wish we could wrap our arms around you
To hug, and kiss and laugh!
Instead, we will settle for loving you
and do our best to stand fast

Your light continues to shine around us
From up there among the stars
It will guide and direct us forwards
as we heal and sooth our scars

(we love and miss you Kelly Bree)

The tree of lights

Tree of lights

One of things that our family looks forward to every year, is the putting up of the Christmas tree. For the kids, it is the start of the festive season and a symbol of the fun times and gifts to come. Kelly loved the delicate decorations and the joy and excitement created on behalf of the kids. I love the triggering of memories of the Christmases past. Both the memories I have shared with my existing family and also those of my childhood and the times spent with my parents and brother.

I had received a piece of paper in the post in the lead up to Christmas this year. A piece of paper I would have normally discarded as junk mail. For some reason, I took the time to read it. It was an invitation to the Tree of Lights ceremony. An opportunity to dedicate a light on a tree to the memory of a loved one. Once read, the invitation seemed fortuitous. Not only was it an opportunity to support the Tygerberg Hospice (an organisation and group of people that I now truly admire and respect), but it was also an opportunity to partake in a ‘Christmassy’ event that would hopefully be memorable to the kids in their future years. Another chance to come together and keep Kelly’s memory alive at a potentially difficult time of the year.

We attended the ceremony and found it to be a lovely event. It included a list of people who shared their own stories about cancer. Stories about survival, about loss, about helping others and about celebrating life. There was articulation and recognition for the great work that people do in palliative care. There was music and food. Most importantly, our attendance had a positive impact on the kids. Emily specifically was engrossed in the stories shared and came away with a deeper awareness of the fact that she is not alone. That other people have had experienced a deep loss and have therefore been on a similar journey to herself. Also, that cancer can be beaten and isn’t necessarily the death sentence that is so often feared. Ethan enjoyed the venue, the bagpipes and the hand-held lights that were handed out after.

The highlight of the event was the switching on of the ‘Tree of lights’. An opportunity for the symbolic lights of our lives to show a tree in all its glory. It was a fitting end to a lovely evening and one that we as a family will remember as we pass through this first Christmas with a special person missing. We left the event with a photo of our little family taken under the special tree. A little keepsake of the night that we remembered a special person who couldn’t put up her own tree of lights this Christmas.

When Singles Day is a conundrum

The 11th of the 11th is singles day. A Chinese unofficial holiday and shopping season that celebrates people who are not in relationship. It isn’t something I would typically remember but a colleague posted a reminder on our work group which lead to a reaction. That reaction being for me to reply that it feels strange to recognise myself as being ‘single’, but I would celebrate it anyway. This led to a bit of dialogue as my reaction caused some guilt in the person who shared the post. To be honest, I missed the point of the post and made something personal. Retrospectively, this was actually selfish on my behalf.

I mention this as it is directly related to the most recent conundrum in my journey. That being the definition of my current status. Am I widowed or single or both? If I am ‘alone’, how long should one wait to meet new people? Can you still grieve somebody and be in a relationship with somebody else? When is too soon and what will other people think? As you can see, there have been lots of questions with one leading to another to another. It is also part of the reason for not blogging for a while. I haven’t really wanted to make that thought process public.

One of my ‘go-to’s’ is to try and go back to the basics. Or to revert to the process. In this case, I go back to the conversations that were had with Kelly during our last days together. Thankfully we had a relationship built on communication and this allowed us to talk about future outcomes or scenarios. Kelly had a view on the matter and took any subjectively out of the equation when discussed. “Mathew, I know that you are going to meet somebody one day. Just make sure that they are the right person for the kids.” That was it. Just a simple statement that bore no judgement and no guilt. I didn’t see the need to argue at the time. Kelly new me best.

This relationship conundrum is a natural occurrence in those who have lost loved ones. It is probably one of the most covered topics on the grief blogs that I have come across. Like everything in life, different people have different views and different approaches to this stage of their journey. In my case, what I have come to realize is that the definition and timing is actually irrelevant. It is not something to be too caught up on. The most important thing was made clear – make sure that the kids are at the forefront of any decision made. That won’t be forgotten.

How to run a marathon

I entered the Cape Town marathon a couple of months back. I thought that I could do with a goal to push myself physically. The marathon is in October and I am a long way off being prepared to run 44km. Kelly’s bestie, who is also running the marathon, has already put in several training runs of 30km x 2 and a 20km. This is on top of the other shorter runs for strength and conditioning. I think that the furthest I had run up until this previous weekend was 10km, once.

Realising that I needed to get some time on the legs, I decided that I was going to try and put in a longer training shift this last Saturday morning. It is worth mentioning that I do the majority of my running on a treadmill these days, which is not my favourite way to train. It is mind numbingly boring and I have to distract myself else time slows to a standstill. Ten kilometers into the run and I was starting to think about pulling out. There were so many excuses that I could use to do so i.e. “with all your responsibility, you don’t have time to train properly”, “nobody expects you to run a marathon so why push yourself”, “the kids would prefer to have you at home on the day anyway”. The list could go on.

Anybody who has exerted themselves would know the self-talk that takes place when you want to give up. Thankfully I have another voice on the other shoulder. It’s the one that says things like “you are not a quitter Mathew”, “if you commit to something then you are going to do it”. Also, I know that the body is stronger than the mind. People are way more capable than they allow themselves to believe. I have always believed that the hardest part of running a marathon is the mental fortitude that is required when the going gets tough. And it always gets tough! Even if you are fitter than most and have the necessary training under the belt.

I thought about a blog post while running because there once again seemed to be a parallel. Life is hard sometimes; we get frustrated and stressed and bored and gatvol. It is just how life is. Like the marathon, you have to stay the course. You have to keep putting one foot in front of the other and keep on keeping on. It’s what gets you to the finish line. Experience tells me that things often change. One minute you are feeling terrible and the next you are suddenly feeling a lot stronger, energised or revived. It happened on the training run and I ended up doing more kilometers than I planned. It made me look forward to the next run where the cycle will likely repeat itself. There is a lesson in that.

Working towards my black belt

Ethan has always wanted to do parkour. Parkour being the street activity where traceurs (practioners) attempt to get from one spot to another spot in the most fluid, and often most acrobatic, means possible. He used to watch youtube footage when he was younger and then replicated what he saw in our living-room, bedroom and garden. A friend recently recommended a gymnastics school that offered parkour classes and I signed Ethan up. Needless to say, he is loving it.

Today is his first ‘mission’ or grading. Its works on a martial arts type system where the student’s progress is assessed, and they increase their rank via the rewarding of a coloured headband. The school promotes the mission as an opportunity to “build self-esteem, resilience, and motivation” as well as “celebrate hard work, effort, and commitment”. It is more of a formality than anything else but taken very seriously none-the-less.

I seem to relate these types of things into my own journey. If I was to do a ‘mission’ and attempt to level-up, what would the criteria for that mission be? Nearly 10 months down the line, what are the training activities that I have repeated over and over to increase proficiency? Is it working through grief and emotions, raising two well-adjusted and happy children, keeping it together and pushing forwards? Also, who gets to decide whether I can move up to the next level and earn the next stripe on the belt?

I realise that this thought process over complicates things un-necessarily. However, the promotion of the mission sparked the thought. One does needs to celebrate hard work, effort and commitment. One does needs to build self-esteem, resilience and motivation. It’s what keeps us walking forward and making progress. I needed the reminder and like the idea. Ethan deserves the headband in recognition of his dedication and effort. He deserves to level up and be proud what he has achieved. Maybe I do too.

When the pot boils over

To state the obvious, this has been a more difficult year than most. Not only have we had to deal with Kelly’s passing but there have been additional stressful events. Restructures at work with my position being made redundant, heart issues requiring ECGs, MRIs and beta-blockers, a leaking roof and then most recently, my mother-in-law (who is dependent on me now) being diagnosed with her own serious health issue which will require longer term care.

In some ways it has felt that the emotional challenges have been stacked on top of each other. One after another after another after another. This on top of having to deal with the stress of work and everyday life. Retrospectively, I like to think that I have dealt with each one relatively well and have come through the other side largely un-scathed thus far. However, there is no doubt that there is one emotion that has become more prominent in the last couple of months as a result. It is an emotion that I am typically not that familiar with as it previously didnt fit my nature nor my character. The said emotion is anger.

It isnt a rage and it isnt volatile. It isn’t directed at anyone and isn’t specific. However when it comes, it is this underlying, deeply ingrained, all consuming anger that has changed me on occasion. It lasts a couple of days, during which time I am less patient, less controlled, less compromising and more easily triggered. It isn’t easy to admit and it isnt something I will try and excuse. It results in a deviation from the norm and guilt. Guilt for irritability, for being less than perfect and for getting the priorities wrong.

I deal with it by acknowledging and accepting. Recognizing it for what it is and remembering that it will eventually wither away. Thankfully I have a strong inner voice, have some routines to reduce the tension and some mindfulness practices to recalibrate the ego and the emotions. Every little bit helps. The ‘episodes’ have become less frequent and are less intense but I dont think that they are gone for good. There is still a little ways to go just yet.

I hesitated to write this blog post because it isnt a nice thing to admit and it could be perceived as a sign of weakness. I worry that people will say something like – “You see, Mathew should be getting some therapy”. They may be right. But I wanted to admit to the emotion because I wanted to make the point that it is actually OK. It is ‘ok’ to be angry or sad or lost or mad. One is entitled to it. We just cant stay in the space for too long and must do all we can to not let it impact on others. We must come back to the norm and get a little better each day. Thats what I am trying to do. In the end I wrote this blog to help myself and help others. It is difficult to remain angry when ones intention is good. That makes the post worthwhile.

Why this self fulfilling prophecy won’t come true

I met with a Doctor a couple of days back and he said something that I have chosen to ignore. I only mention that he was an Doctor as it adds some gravitas to the person who made the statement. He had asked me about Kelly’s passing and how many children we had. First I mentioned that I had a daughter aged 10. Next I mentioned I had a son aged 7. His response, “Ah! He is the one that is going to be messed up by this”. I think I nodded and said something along the lines of “yeah, I need to keep an eye on him”. I didn’t think a debate about hypothetical outcomes would have been appropriate under the circumstances.

The Doctor had a personal story about the loss of his mother to cancer and explained that his own younger brothers hadn’t turned out as well as he had. It was a touching story and he clearly cared for them all. The thing about the statement was the conviction with which it was said. There appeared to be no hesitation or hint of disbelief in his premise. It was true for him and therefore for everybody else. It was one of those scenario’s where somebody says something and then look you in the eye knowingly. In his mind, this wasn’t going to end well for the younger brother.

The thing about the statement is that it could become the classic example of the self fulfilling prophecy. This struck me immediately and I chose to deliberate on it as it I feel that the concept is one that can be flipped on its head. Yes, there is a prophecy that could be fulfilled. It is one where Ethan turns out great. It is one where my positive energy, love and presence ensures that he does just fine. He is ultimately happy and content and satisfied. That is the outcome that I choose to direct my energy into and believe. That is my own prophecy.

If you read the literature about the self fulfilling prophecy, it is clear it is a complex thing. How much is in the power of the believer, and how much is in the power of the receiver? All I know is that should I have chosen to take on the debate, I might have said something like this “It’s interesting you say that but I believe that every scenario is different, every family is different, every person is different. I strongly believe that the kids will turn out alright. Yes, they are going to have some issues and tough times but I am confident that this is going to make them stronger and more resilient.” It’s going to be interesting to see whose prophecy comes true. Doctor dread or myself. I suspect I already know the answer.